Harun Yahya

A reply to Andya Primanda

Andya Primanda, an Indonesian Muslim paleontologist, has recently been criticizing books and articles posted on the website harunyahya.com which reject the theory of evolution. Primanda, who has stated that he believes in God - and so we assume that he believes in the creation - is probably influenced by the Darwinist dogma that dominates the paleoanthropological world. He insistently argues for the theory of evolution and states that he finds the criticisms brought against evolution incorrect. However, as we will see below, Primanda is mistaken in both his belief in the theory of evolution and his criticisms against those who point out the flaws in evolutionary theory.

 
PRIMANDA'S MISCONCEPTIONS REGARDING SAHELANTHROPUS
 
Primanda's chief contention is against interpretations made concerning a skull found some time ago in Chad that was given the name Sahelanthropus tchadensis. In an article on the skull entitled "New Fossil Discovery Sinks Evolutionary Theories" recently posted on the Harun Yahya website, we stated that the seven-million-year-old Sahelanthropus tchadensis, despite its advanced age, was more "human like" compared to the genus Australopithecus, which is younger and which has been presented as a primitive ancestor of humans. We wrote that this evidence would pull the evolutionary tree out by its roots.
 
Primanda, in his response to us, rejected our interpretation and throughout his article, he claimed that Sahelanthropus was more "ape like" than Australopithecus in every respect. He wrote:
 
HY based his statements on the assumption that Sahelanthropus displayed 'more human-like attributes' than australopiths (Australopithecus, Paranthropus, Ardipithecus), yet living before them.
 
However, Primanda ignores an important fact. Those who made this comment on Sahelanthropus were the scientists who found this fossil and examined it, and these scientists are also proponents of evolutionary theory. An article published in Nature magazine said:
 
What is remarkable about the chimp sized cranium TM 266-01-060-1 discovered by Brunet et al. is its mosaic nature. Put simply from the back it looks like a chimpanzee, whereas from the front it could pass for a 1.75-million-year-old advanced australopith. The hominid features involve the structure of the face, and the small, apically worn, canine crowns. Other hominid features are found in the base of the cranium and in the separate jaw fragment. If we accept these as sufficient evidence to classify S.tchadensis as a hominid at the base, or stem, of the modern human clade, then it plays havoc with the tidy model of human origins. Quite simply, a hominid of this age should only just be beginning to show signs of being a hominid. It certainly should not have the face of a hominid less than one-third of its geological age. Also if it is accepted as a stem hominid, under the tidy model the principle of parsimony dictates that all creatures with more primitive faces (and that is a very long list) would, perforce, have to be excluded from the ancestry of modern humans.1
 
Briefly, the fossil presents a picture that runs counter to the "evolutionary scheme" which has been imposed on the society for over a century, since Darwin. This contradiction is so striking that the Nature writer compares the discovery of this fossil to the Burgess Shale fossils that demonstrate the Cambrian Explosion, which constitutes perhaps the best-known paleontological evidence against Darwin's theory:
 
The fauna of the Burgess Shale in Canada, which samples a bewildering array of ivertebrate groups some 500 million years ago, is a famous example of diversity at the base of an adaptive radiation. Does S.tchadensis belong to the African ape equivalent of the Burgess Shale? 2
 
The theory of evolution is unable to explain the Cambrian Explosion, the sudden appearance of over 60 animal phyla on our planet. It also fails to explain the origin of humankind. The recently discovered fossil makes this deficiency even more obvious. Primanda is opposed to our revealing this fact, which is a pointless criticism.
 
Faced with this fact, what Primanda wants to do is to show that Sahelanthropus' relatively modern characteristics do not actually exist. He discusses two characteristics, prognathism and foramen magnum position, but his analysis is quite shallow. His examination of prognathism is nothing but superimposing the outlines of Sahelanthropus on some hominid fossils, and he himself admits that "this method of comparison may be flawed" and that "the results may not be of high value."
 
His explanation of the foramen magnum is a dodge. This is also seen in his illustration based on foramen magnum position; when compared to Australopithecus, Sahelanthropus is more modern. And this confirms what we have been arguing from the very beginning, that is that Sahelanthropus, despite being older than Australopithecus, had more modern features, and therefore an evolutionary chart based on these features cannot be formed. Primanda made a show of responding to this statement in writing, "Sahelanthropus falls nicely in an intermediate position, between ape and human positions," but this misses the point entirely. The point is the comparison between Sahelanthropus and Australopithecus.
 
THE DISCUSSION ON AUSTRALOPITHECUS
 
At this point, Primanda refers to our explanation of Australopithecus and criticizes the work of Zuckerman, Oxnard and Spoor. He also wrote that Spoor's studies have changed. It's a fact that the locomotion of Australopithecus is a contradictory issue. The common view is that members of this genus were arboreal, and that they used their two feet when they walked on the ground. It's accepted that the usage of these two feet was not like that of humans, but was in fact quite different, and constituted a much more bent mode of locomotion as compared to humans.
 
What would it prove if Australopithecus was moving more erectly than the apes that exist today? Today the world has a rich variety of ape species, and it's no great leap to assume that this variety was even greater in the past and that this also applies to their mode of locomotion. What's key here is that an evolutionary arrangement cannot be put together among these ape types.
 
There is yet an even more important point which puts the theory of evolution into a big quandary regarding its scenario about the origin of man and other species: The mechanisms that would allegedly turn this scenario into reality are wholly imaginary. If you examine the evolutionist account, it says that these creatures got used to walking after they came down from the trees, and their skeletons became more erect since they had to assume a straighter posture when they walked across the savannah. Their hands were empty so they used their hands, and this led their brains to develop. This sounds like a fairy tale based on Lamarckian logic, such as the evolution of the body according to emerging needs and the inheritance of acquired traits. But that's just how this is foisted on the public. (Needless to say, Lamarckism is utter sophistry).
When we probe this account more closely, we see that the only possible mechanism behind this fairy tale is the natural selection-mutation dyad. However, all experiments and observations show that these mechanisms do not provide an increase in genetic information.
 
Looking at this evolutionary account together with natural selection and the mutation mechanism suffices to demonstrate that this is nonsense. The Australopithecus which was trying to stand erect on the savannah must have had such a mutation so he would gain a straighter skeleton, a balance mechanism needed for this skeleton, a foramen magnum and a muscle mechanism, and he mustn't have suffered any ill effects from this mutation. (However, this is impossible because of the pleiotropic effect.) Moreover, this imaginary mutant must have been superior to other mutants of his species only because he was able to see higher parts of the tall grasses, and he must have reproduced and started a new species. All other physical and mental characteristics that make us human must have been created through such random mutations; all these transformations must have taken place through these accidental mutations. This is nothing but a dream, or in the words of Henry Gee, the editor of Nature, a "bedtime story."3 On the other hand, famous French biologist Pierre-Paul Grasse once said, "There is no law against daydreaming, but science must not indulge in it." 4
 
Therefore Primanda, in the article mentioned earlier, has no basis other than Darwinist prejudice for criticizing our view that Australopithecus was a unique ape genus unrelated to human beings which later became extinct.
 
DISCUSSIONS ON BUSHES AND PRIMANDA'S CONTRADICTION
 
Primanda bases his views on imaginary evidence, and he presents contradictory criticism against us. One of his criticisms is that Bernard Wood's view of the evolution of man looks like a bush rather than a ladder. Primanda writes:
 
HY failed on two counts:
 
1) As shown before, Sahelanthropus does not show more humanlike characteristics than australopithecines;
 
2) 'The evolutionist scheme', 'the ladder from ape to man' is a strawman.
 
The prevailing scientific view is currently shifting to another perspective. HY quotes Bernard Wood, which said that '...human evolutionary history was a ladder in the 1960s...but it looks like a bush now'. As a matter of fact, this change of evolutionary thought was due to the ever-expanding human fossil record, with new and unexpected discoveries pouring in every few years.
 
So what? In the midst of criticizing us, Primanda repeats exactly the facts that we had already stated. Yes, the evolutionary account no longer looks like a "tree" but rather a "bush," and this is because the evidence unearthed fits neither the 150-year-old Darwinist tree of life nor any evolutionary arrangement. Primanda and others are still trying to cobble together an "evolutionary hypothesis" from this bush, but in the end we have this concrete truth: The fossils do not support Darwinism. The evolutionist community thought that the more fossils they found, the stronger evolutionary theory would become, but in fact it was the other way around. Niles Eldredge from Harvard University, one of the
United States' leading paleontologists, and Ian Tattersall from the American Museum of Natural History once wrote:
 
It is a myth that the evolutionary histories of living things are essentially a matter of discovery. If this were true, one could confidently expect that as more hominid fossils were found the story of human evolution would become clearer. Whereas if anything, the opposite has occured. 5
 
One point here especially deserves underlining: replacing the "tree" with a "bush" is not the result of evidence, but rather of a lack of evidence. Yes, many fossils have been found but these constitute evidence against the theory of evolution. The only way out for the evolutionists was to come up with a "bush" model to replace the tree so as to be able to depict this chaos. The bush model is nothing but an excuse conjured up to explain away the body of fossil evidence which contradicts Darwinism.
 
If you believe blindly in evolutionary theory, you would try to interpret every new finding so as to support this theory. Marxists who believe blindly in Marxism sought refuge in excuses such as Leninism when the promised revolution failed to take place. Prejudiced people can always come up with an artificial explanation to every problem. An unprejudiced person, however, can easily see the real situation: the concrete data do not fit this theory.
 
ALLEGATIONS OF A DISTORTION OF GEE
 
One of Primanda's criticisms was that Nature magazine's editor Henry Gee had been misquoted by us:
 
HY also misquoted Henry Gee, which said that 'The idea of the missing link … is now completely untenable.'
 
This allegation is completely unfounded. Below we reproduce one of Gee's lengthier explanations in order to dispel any doubts on this matter:
 
A seven-million-year-old skull found in a central African desert is probably the most important discovery in the search for human origins in living memory - since Raymond Dart announced the "ape man" Australopithecus africanus in 1925. Yet its initial effect may be to confuse rather than enlighten. Whatever the outcome, the skull shows, once and for all, that the old idea of a "missing link" is bunk...
Why is Toumaï so important? First, it is the earliest known credible vestige of a hominid - a member of the group of creatures more closely related to human beings than to any other animals. It also doubles the antiquity of the earliest known skull: the previous recordholder, from Kenya, is around 3.3m years old.
 
Second, it has dropped straight into the most crucial, but least known, part of the story of human evolution. It is suspected that the last common ancestor of humans and our closest living relatives, the chimpanzees, lived around 7m years ago. We know this not from direct fossil evidence, but from studying the small differences in the otherwise similar genes of humans and chimps, and estimating the time needed for these differences to accrue.
 
Looking at the fossil evidence itself, we see a huge and frustrating gap. Ten million years ago, the world was full of apes, but there is no agreement about which of these stand closest to the evolution of humans. In any case, a distinct lineage leading to humans, as distinct from chimps, would not have existed back then...
 
So what does Toumaï look like? It is a mixture of primitive and disconcertingly advanced traits. The braincase has the same size and shape as a chimpanzee. The face, though, is where the interest lies. Rather than having a projecting snout with large canine teeth, the face is flat and the teeth are very small and human-like. Strangest of all are the enormous brow-ridges. These are usually associated with our own genus Homo, and are not otherwise seen in anything older than about 2m years...
 
People and advertising copywriters tend to see human evolution as a line stretching from apes to man, into which one can fit new-found fossils as easily as links in a chain. Even modern anthropologists fall into this trap, accepting a certain bushiness in the human family tree between 3m and 2m years ago - when the genus Homo first emerged - but thinking of human evolution before then as, essentially, linear. Wood thinks it was bushiness all the way down. Recent research to put tabs on how much we really know of the past supports this view, suggesting that we have direct evidence of only 7% of all the primate species that ever lived.
 
This means three things. First, that we tend to look at those few tips of the bush we know about, connect them with lines, and make them into a linear sequence of ancestors and descendants that never was. But it should now be quite plain that the very idea of the missing link, always shaky, is now completely untenable. 6
 
Briefly, Gee is saying that the model for human evolution comes "not from direct fossil evidence," that there is "a huge and frustrating gap" in the fossil record, and that therefore the view of the "missing link" is also "completely untenable." This is what we have been saying from the beginning. Therefore Primanda's allegation that Gee was misquoted is entirely unfair.
 
PRIMANDA'S DOGMATISM
 
Primanda's dogmatism is even more interesting. Right after his unfounded allegation against us about the Gee quote, he wrote:
 
Of course there is no such thing as 'the' missing link. Every organism, living or fossil, is a link between those which existed before and those which existed after. Each one is a transitional form; there is not one which can be assigned as the missing link, the turning point, the mark of change from one type to another. Evolutionary change is gradual.
 
In claiming this, Primanda is changing the definition of "transitional form," or - better put - distorting it. Transitional form, since Darwin, does not refer to existing species, but instead is the name given to theoretical ancestors that are assumed to have lived in the past and are separated from each other by very minor morphological differences. If every living thing were a transitional form, then Darwin wouldn't have suffered for page after page in The Origin of the Species trying to explain why these transitional forms were nowhere to be found.
Paleontologists wouldn't have spent the last 150 years digging up the four corners of the earth in an attempt to find these forms.
 
In other words, due to the lack of these transitional forms, Primanda finds shelter in a superficial explanation, namely that "every organism is a transitional form." Only a child could believe such an assertion, because reality says just the opposite. In fact, more serious evolutionists admit this fact. For instance, Robert Carroll, a leading authority on evolution, writes:
 
Although an almost incomprehensible number of species inhabit Earth today, they do not form a continuous spectrum of barely distinguishable intermediates. Instead, nearly all species can be recognized as belonging to a relatively limited number of clearly distinct major groups, with very few illustrating intermediate structures or ways of life. 7
 
THE MOLECULAR MISTAKE
 
Primanda's other article, titled An Invitation to the Facts: Response to Chapter 9
of The Evolution Deceit," which he prepared as a response to the chapter of "The Evolution Deceit" dealing with human origins, also contains significant errors.
 
Those who read the title of this article might be led to think that it presents an extensive response. However, the only claim in it worthy of attention is the assertion that there is a molecular (genetic) similarity between chimpanzees and man. Primanda says that there is a 99 percent similarity and that therefore we can't deny that humans and apes are relatives, which is just where he makes his great mistake: there is no such genetic similarity. A scientific finding on this issue that was announced just a few weeks ago revealed that this genetic similarity had been exaggerated and the true figure was actually less than 95 percent. Our article, called "The 99% Myth Is Dead," lays all this out in detail and in doing so refutes Primanda's allegation of molecular similarity, which apparently is his strongest ammunition.
 
CONCLUSION
 
Despite his loyalty towards Darwinism, Primanda says that he is a believing Muslim. We respect that. But we would be remiss not to point out the contradiction between his faith in Islam and Darwinism. He should ask himself: If he is a believing Muslim, why is he defending a theory which is championed by outright and militant atheists? If he is a believing Muslim, why is he working to defend this theory, which is the basis for Marxism, Leninism, Maoism, Freudianism, and, most importantly, all materialist philosophy? He shouldn't try to answer these questions by saying that he's doing this for the sake of science, because today the entire world knows that Darwinism is not a scientific theory, but rather a philosophy. It is a philosophy whose very reason for existence is to deny creation and the Creator.
 
We can only hope that Primanda will be able to tear himself away from the bewitching effects of this philosophy and begin to see things as they really are.

___________________________________________
 
(1) Bernard Wood, "Hominid Revelations from Chad", Nature, 11 July 2002, p. 134.
(2) Bernard Wood, "Hominid Revelations from Chad", Nature, 11 July 2002, p. 135.
(3) Henry Gee, In Search of Deep Time, New York, The Free Press, 1999, s. 116-117.
(4) Pierre-P Grassé, Evolution of Living Organisms, Academic Press, New York, 1977, p. 103.
(5) Niles Eldredge, Ian Tattersall, The Myths of Human Evolution, p. 126-127
(6) "Face Of Yesterday: Henry Gee On The Dramatic Discovery Of A Seven-Million-Year-Old Hominid" The Guardian, July 11, 2002.
(7) Robert L. Carroll, Patterns and Processes of Vertebrate Evolution, Cambridge University Press, 1997, p. 9.

Desktop View

 

 

iddialaracevap.org adnanoktarhaber.com adnanoktarhukuk.com adnanoktargercekleri.net
GAZETECİ RUŞEN ÇAKIR'A AÇIK MEKTUP
@DREYFUS.TURK İSİMLİ INSTAGRAM SAYFASININ CAMİAMIZLA HİÇBİR İLGİSİ VE...
ASTRONOMİK CEZALAR İÇİN "HAYALİ KIZLARIN İFFETİNİ KORUMA" GEREKÇESİ
ADNAN OKTAR DAVASI: YARGILANMADAN MÜEBBET
ANAL TECAVÜZ TEKNİK OLARAK İMKANSIZDIR. BU KONUDA ALEYHİMİZE YAPILAN...
KUMPASÇILARIN HEDEFİNDE BU KEZ DE INSTAGRAM, TWITTER VE DİĞER SOSYAL MEDYA...
YARGILAMA HAKKINDAKİ GERÇEKLER VE BAZI BASINDAKİ BOŞA SEVİNÇ NİDALARI
SAYIN BARIŞ TERKOĞLU’NA AÇIK MEKTUP
TEK CÜMLELİK İFTİRAYLA MASUM BİR GENÇ KIZA 40 YIL HAPİS CEZASI
ADNAN OKTAR DAVASINDA "18 YAŞIN ALTINDAKİ KIZLARIN İSTİSMARI" YALANI
EBRU ŞİMŞEK OLAYININ İÇYÜZÜ
SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR’IN 10 BİN YILLIK CEZAYI GÜLEREK KARŞILAMASI BAZI...
DAVA DOSYAMIZDA TEK BİR DOĞAL MÜŞTEKİ YOKTUR
CAMİAMIZDA EVLİLİK BEKLENTİSİNE KAVUŞAMAYAN BAZI KIZLAR BUNUN HINCIYLA...
GERÇEK DIŞI HABERCİLİĞİ BENİMSEYEN BİR KISIM BASIN HALKIN GÖZÜNDE GÜVEN VE...
HİÇBİR SUÇ OLMADIĞINI ÇOK İYİ BİLDİKLERİ İÇİN RESMİ MAKAMLAR ARAMIZA POLİS...
DOSYADAKİ SADECE 25 MÜŞTEKİ VE ETKİN PİŞMAN SANIĞIN İFADELERİNDEKİ 1000'E...
YABANCI HUKUKÇU VE AKADEMİSYENLER, ADNAN OKTAR DAVASINDAKİ ETKİN PİŞMAN...
CUMHURİYET GAZETESİNE CEVAP
SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR'IN YAKIN ZAMANDA MAHKEMEYE SUNDUĞU BAZI KISA BEYAN...
ETKİN PİŞMAN OLMAYA ZORLANAN ARKADAŞLARIMIZA OYNANAN OYUN
SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR'IN YAKIN ZAMANDA MAHKEMEYE SUNDUĞU BAZI KISA BEYAN...
TÜRKİYE'DE HUKUK RAFA MI KALKTI?
"FİKREN İKTİDAR OLMAK" ANCAK SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR'IN İLMİ VE FİKRİ...
'ORAL YOLDAN TECAVÜZ' İDDİALARI GERÇEK DIŞIDIR
CAMİAMIZA YÖNELİK 2 YILLIK GİZLİ TEKNİK TAKİPTE TEK BİR SUÇ DELİLİ DAHİ...
ESKİ TAKİPSİZLİK VE ZAMAN AŞIMI KARARLARI YARGILANANLAR ALEYHİNDE...
ÇİZGİ ROMANLARLA, PORNO FİLMLERDEN ALINAN GÖRÜNTÜLERLE KARALAMALAR YAPMAYA...
ADNAN OKTAR HİÇBİR ZAMAN “NAMAZI MİNİ ETEKLE KILABİLİRSİNİZ” DEMEMİŞTİR...
Sn. Adnan Oktar’ın Mahkemede Söylediği Son Sözü
GAZETECİ SAYIN İSMAİL SAYMAZ 'A AÇIK MEKTUP
BASIN MENSUPLARIMIZI ADİL VE TARAFSIZ HABERCİLİĞE DAVET EDİYORUZ
ADNAN OKTAR DAVASINDAKİ HTS KAYITLARI HUKUKEN SUÇLAYICI YÖNDE DELİL OLARAK...
SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR’IN İSMİNİ KOYMASININ ARDINDAN BİRÇOK DEVLET BÜYÜĞÜMÜZ VE...
15 TEMMUZ DARBE GİRİŞİMİNE KARŞI ÇIKMAK, FETÖ'NÜN İNFAZ LİSTESİNE GİRMEK...
İDDİANAMEDE, SN ADNAN OKTAR'IN KENDİSİNİ GÜYA "MEHDİ RESUL" İLAN ETTİĞİNE...
15 TEMMUZ DARBE GİRİŞİMİ GECESİ SN. ADNAN OKTAR'IN A9 TV'DEN GECE BOYUNCA...
SN. ADNAN OKTAR, ESKİ GAZETECİ MEHMET BARANSU İLE SADECE BİR KEZ, 2011...
İDDİANAMEDE, KANDİLLİ'DEKİ EVDE SÖZDE "KULE" OLARAK ADLANDIRILAN BİR ODADA...
CAMİAMIZA DÜZENLENEN OPERASYONDA "GENELEV VE FUHUŞ MAFYASI" ÖNEMLİ BİR ROL...
İDDİANAMEDEKİ EVLİLİK KONUSUNDAKİ SUÇ İSNATLARI GEÇERSİZDİR
15 ARALIK 2020 SALI GÜNÜ YAYINLANAN "ADNAN OKTAR ARKADAŞ GRUBUNA...
FETÖ’YE YARDIM İDDİASI BÜYÜK BİR İFTİRADIR
CUMHURBAŞKANLIĞI YÜKSEK İSTİŞARE KURULU (YİK) ÜYESİ SAYIN CEMİL ÇİÇEK...
SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR'IN HİÇBİR ZAMAN MEHDİLİK İDDİASI OLMADIĞI GİBİ MEHDİLİK...
GERÇEKTE YAŞANTISI ÇİLE VE SIKINTILARLA DOLU OLAN SN. ADNAN OKTAR’IN “LÜKS...
SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR'IN, DEĞERLİ OSMANLI PADİŞAHI SULTAN II. ABDÜLHAMİD HAN'I...
İSRAİLLİ SİYASİLER VE SANHEDRİN HAHAMLARI, TÜRKİYE-İSRAİL İLİŞKİLERİ...
ARKADAŞIMIZ AYŞE KOÇ'UN, 13 KASIM 2020 TARİHİNDE KATILDIĞI BİR TV...
MİLLİYET GAZETESİ MAGAZİN YAZARI SN. ALİ EYÜBOĞLU’NA AÇIK MEKTUP–2
KUMPAS ÇETESİ SON ÇAREYİ KASET İMASI YALANINA SARILMAKTA ARIYOR
SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR VE ARKADAŞLARININ SİVİL DİPLOMASİ FAALİYETLERİNİN...
HALK TV, MEDYA MAHALLESİ PROGRAMINDA ORTAYA ATILAN İDDİALARA CEVAPLARIMIZ
ESKİ SAĞLIK BAKANIMIZ SAYIN OSMAN DURMUŞ’UN VEFATI ÜZERİNE ÇIKAN HABERLERE...
MAVİ MARMARA FACİASINDA, İSRAİL'İN TÜRKİYE'DEN ÖZÜR DİLEYİP TAZMİNAT...
FOSİLLERİN ARTIK DEVLETİMİZ ELİYLE MÜZELERDE SERGİLENECEK OLMASI...
FETÖ BAĞLANTISI YALANI
ŞEREF MALKOÇ AĞABEYİMİZDEN RİCAMIZDIR
MEDYAMIZ ÖZKAN MAMATİ İSİMLİ KİŞİNİN GERÇEK YÜZÜNÜ MUTLAKA BİLMELİDİR
HAKLARINDA HİÇBİR KESİN YARGI KARARI OLMAYAN SN. ADNAN OKTAR VE...
MERVE BÜYÜKBAYRAK AKIL HASTANESİNE SEVK TALEBİ GEREKTİRECEK NE YAPTI?
BASINA ÖZEL HAZIRLANAN SENARYOLARLA HAKKIMIZDA ALGI OLUŞTURULMAYA...
MİLLİYET GAZETESİ MAGAZİN YAZARI SAYIN ALİ EYÜBOĞLU’NA AÇIK MEKTUP
AYRILIP DAĞILMA GİBİ BİR NİYETİMİZ ASLA YOK!
YENİ ŞAFAK GAZETESİ YAZARI SAYIN HASAN ÖZTÜRK’E AÇIK MEKTUP
SAYIN ÖZLEM GÜRSES'E AÇIK MEKTUP
SAYIN MİNE UZUN'A AÇIK MEKTUP
DAVA DOSYASI BOMBOŞ ÇIKINCA MEDET UMULAN ESKİ BİR İFTİRA: "GİZLİ TÜNELDEN...
KONUNUN TARAFLARINA SÖZ HAKKI VERMEDEN TEK TARAFLI YAYIN YAPMASI HABERTÜRK...
SAYIN AHMET HAKAN'A AÇIK MEKTUP
HALK TV'YE AÇIK MEKTUP
OZAN SÜER ARKADAŞIMIZIN TUTUKLANMASIYLA İLGİLİ OLARAK AV. SENA AKKAYA...
TÜRK İNSANI ADİL, TARAFSIZ, DÜRÜST, İLKELİ VE SEVGİ DOLU BİR BASIN ÖZLEMİ...
İFTİRA ÜZERİNE KURULAN DAVAMIZIN TEMELİNDEKİ SEBEP: "HUSUMET"
HÜRRİYET GAZETESİ VE YAZARLARINA CESARETLE VE ISRARLA DOĞRUDAN YANA OLMAK...
SEVGİ, KARDEŞLİK VE SELAM GÖNDERME İDDİALARI TUTUKLAMA GEREKÇESİ OLAMAZ
MEHDİYET İNANCI SEBEBİYLE SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR’IN YANINDAN AYRILMADIĞIMIZ...
TOPLU BİR AKIL TUTULMASI: "GALEYAN"
ELVAN KOÇAK BEY’İN YANLIŞ BİLGİLENDİRİLDİĞİ HUSUSLAR
AV. CELAL ÜLGEN'E AÇIK MEKTUP–3
İNGİLİZ DERİN DEVLETİNİN ÜLKEMİZDEKİ ALÇAK, HAİN VE AŞAĞILIK KRİPTO...
SAYIN MİNE KIRIKKANAT HANIMEFENDİ’YE BİR KEZ DAHA DOSTLUK VE SEVGİ...
MÜŞTEKİ İFADELERİ HAKKINDA BASINDA YER ALAN GERÇEK DIŞI HABERLER
SEVGİDEN VAZGEÇMEK ZULÜM OLUR, TEK İSTEĞİMİZ SEVGİ TOPLUMU OLUŞMASI
2 YILDAN BU YANA CAMİAMIZA KARŞI YAPILAN HAK VE HUKUK İHLALLERİ, ZULÜM VE...
ALİ İHSAN KARAHASANOĞLU KARDEŞİMİZ MASUMİYET KARİNESİNE VE SAVUNMA HAKKINA...
ATV KAHVALTI HABERLERİNDEKİ ASILSIZ İTHAMLARA CEVABIMIZDIR
MİLLİ ÇÖZÜM DERGİSİ BAŞYAZARI AHMET AKGÜL’ÜN İFTİRALARA DAYANARAK YAPTIĞI...
SEVGİYE DAİR HER DAVRANIŞIN SUÇ KAPSAMINA SOKULMA GAYRETİNDEN ENDİŞE...
AV. SN. CELAL ÜLGEN'E AÇIK MEKTUP
CÜBBELİ AHMET HOCAMIZ’DAN MÜSLÜMANLAR HAKKINDA KONUŞURKEN ADİL, DÜRÜST VE...
İSTİKLAL İNTERNET HABER SİTESİ YAZARLARINDAN SAYIN ÖMER AKDAĞ’A...
MADDİ GELİR ELDE ETMEK UĞRUNA TERTEMİZ, NUR GİBİ İNSANLARI ACIMASIZCA YOK...
DOSYAMIZDA ETKİN PİŞMANLIK İFADELERİ DEĞİL, CAN HAVLİYLE KENDİNİ...
SAYIN MİNE KIRIKKANAT HANIMIN SAVUNMA HAKKINI VE DEĞERLİ AVUKATLARI HEDEF...
BASIN KORKU DEĞİL ADALET, DÜRÜSTLÜK VE TARAFSIZLIK ÜZERİNE KURULU YAYIN...
AKİT'TEKİ KARDEŞLERİMİZ YAYINLARINDAKİ HAKARETAMİZ ÜSLUBA KARŞI MUTLAKA...
SN. ADNAN OKTAR DURUŞMALAR BOYUNCA MASKE KULLANMIŞ, GENEL SAĞLIĞIN...
MÜMİN ALLAH’TAN GELEN İŞARETLERİ GÖRÜR VE HAYRA YORAR
KANAL D ANA HABER PROGRAMINI HUKUK VE VİCDAN SINIRLARI İÇİNDE YAYIN...
ARKADAŞIMIZ BÜLENT SEZGİN'DEN SAYIN AYŞENUR ARSLAN HANIMEFENDİ’YE AÇIK...
SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR VE ARKADAŞLARINI GÜYA TEHLİKELİYMİŞ GİBİ GÖSTERME OYUNU
ARKADAŞIMIZ SERDAR SUPHİ TOGAY'IN MAHKEME İFADESİNDEN BASINA YANSIYAN...
SÖZDE ETKİN PİŞMAN OLMAK ZORUNDA BIRAKILAN ARKADAŞIMIZ ALİ ŞEREF GİDER’İN...
TURNİKE İFTİRASINA İTİBAR EDİP DİLE GETİRENLERİN ASIL ÖNCELİĞİ...
AKİT CAMİASINDAKİ KARDEŞLERİMİZ BİZİM İYİ NİYETİMİZİ YAKINDAN BİLİR VE...
GERÇEKLER SAYIN DOĞAN KASADOLU'NUN HAYAL DÜNYASINDA YAŞADIĞINDAN VE...
ALİ İHSAN KARAHASANOĞLU KARDEŞİMİZE HANIMLAR HAKKINDA SAYGILI VE NEZAKETLİ...
MUHAFAZAKAR CAMİADA HAKKIMIZDA MERAK EDİLEN BAZI SORULARA CEVAPLAR
DURUŞMADA YÖNELTİLEN SORULAR İDDİANAMEDE YER ALAN SUÇLAMALARIN ASILSIZ...
ARKADAŞIMIZ SEDAT ALTAN'DAN DEĞERLİ GAZETECİMİZ SAYIN AHMET HAKAN'A AÇIK...
ARKADAŞIMIZ MERVE BÜYÜKBAYRAK'IN MİNE KIRIKKANAT HANIMEFENDİ'YE AÇIK...
ARKADAŞIMIZ KARTAL İŞ'TEN SAYIN DOĞU PERİNÇEK’E AÇIK MEKTUP
AV. SN. KEREM ALTIPARMAK’IN “İNTERNET ERİŞİM ENGELLERİ VE İFADE ÖZGÜRLÜĞÜ”...
"NİHAYET DERGİSİ"NDE, CAMİAMIZ HAKKINDA YAPILMIŞ GERÇEK DIŞI, ÇİRKİN BİR...
HALKI, HALKA EZDİREN SİSTEM SON BULMALI
KONU DEKOLTE DEĞİL, SEVGİMİZE VE DOSTLUĞUMUZA DUYULAN ÖFKE
INDEPENDENT-TÜRKÇE'NİN MÜSLÜMANLARA EVRİM TEORİSİNİ KABUL ETTİRME TAKTİĞİ
BUGÜN BAZI GAZETECİLERİN TUTUKLANMASINI ELEŞTİREN CNN TÜRK GECE GÖRÜŞÜ...
DEKOLTE GİYDİLER DİYE MASUM İNSANLARA YÜZLERCE YIL HAPİS CEZASI İSTEYİP...
SN. ADNAN OKTAR’IN MEHDİLİK İLAN EDEREK DEVLETİ ELE GEÇİRECEĞİ İTHAMI AKLA...
ARKADAŞIMIZ EMRE BUKAĞILI'NIN SN. FAZIL SAYIN AÇIKLAMALARINA CEVABI
SÜLEYMAN ÖZIŞIK KARDEŞİMİZİN DE CEMAATLERİN MİLLETİMİZ İÇİN DEĞERİNİ ÇOK...
ADNAN OKTAR OLMASAYDI...
SAYIN ERGUN YILDIRIM’IN “YENİ MEHDİLER” BAŞLIKLI KÖŞE YAZISINA...
NORMAL VE LEGAL BİR YAŞAMDAN YAPAY SUÇLAR ÜRETİLEREK "HAYALİ BİR SUÇ...
SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR’IN TUTUKLANMASININ ARDINDAN...
CÜBBELİ AHMET HOCAMIZ MÜSLÜMANLARA ATILAN İFTİRALARA İTİBAR ETMEMELİDİR
ODATV GENEL YAYIN YÖNETMENİ SN. BARIŞ PEHLİVAN'A AÇIK MEKTUP
KOMPLOCULAR, KORKUTARAK "SÖZDE" İTİRAFÇI YAPTIKLARI ARKADAŞLARIMIZ...
CUMHURİYET GAZETESİNE AÇIK MEKTUP
GENİŞ HAYAL GÜCÜ İLE KURGULANAN DAVA DOSYASI
MODERNLİK İSLAM’IN GELİŞİP YAYILMASINDA EN ETKİLİ YÖNTEMDİR
SN. ENVER AYSEVER’İN PROGRAMINDA GÜNDEME GELEN İTHAMLARIN CEVAPLARI
SN. ADNAN OKTAR: "ALLAH'IN VERECEĞİ KARARI TALEP EDİYORUM"
MİNE KIRIKKANAT GİBİ AYDIN VE DEMOKRAT BİR HANIMA HUKUKUN TEMEL İLKELERİNE...
Adnan Oktar: "Allah’ın vereceği kararı talep ediyorum."
Adnan Oktar: "Allah’ın vereceği kararı talep ediyorum."
YENİ AKİT GAZETESİ VE ODA TV’DE YER ALAN “UYAP’TAN SANIĞIN ADI SİLİNDİ”...
SAYIN BİRCAN BALİ'YE CEVAP
SAYIN AVUKAT CELAL ÜLGEN'E AÇIK MEKTUP
SAYIN ALİ İHSAN KARAHASANOĞLU'NA CEVAP
SAYIN ADNAN OKTAR VE CAMİAMIZA YÖNELİK MANEVİ LİNÇ
SN. DOĞU PERİNÇEK VE SN. PROF. DR. ALİ DEMİRSOY'UN ÖNEMLİ OLDUĞUNU...
SAYIN PROF. DR. NURAN YILDIZ'A AÇIK MEKTUP
SN. ADNAN OKTAR VE ARKADAŞLARININ İSRAİL VE MUSEVİLERLE OLAN...
CAMİAMIZA YÖNELİK "YURTDIŞI LOBİ FAALİYETLERİ" İSNADI İLE İLGİLİ...
FETÖ'YE KARŞI EN GÜÇLÜ ELEŞTİRİLERİ SN. ADNAN OKTAR YAPMIŞTIR
DELİL VE ŞAHİT OLMADAN SUÇSUZ İNSANLARI CEZALANDIRMAK KUR’AN’A UYGUN...
ARKADAŞLARIMIZ MUAZZEZ VE YILDIZ ARIK’IN DURUŞMADAKİ GERÇEK DIŞI...
İNSANLARA NEREDE VE KİMLERLE YAŞAYACAKLARINA DAİR BASKI VE DAYATMADA...
ARKADAŞIMIZ BERİL KONCAGÜL’ÜN DURUŞMADAKİ GERÇEK DIŞI İDDİALARINA...
KANAL D'NİN UYDURMA HABERİ
MERVE BOZYİĞİT'İN DURUŞMADAKİ AÇIKLAMALARI KUMPASI GÖZLER ÖNÜNE SERDİ !!!
ARKADAŞLARIMIZ ALTUĞ ETİ, BURAK ABACI VE CEYHUN GÖKDOĞAN'IN...
KUMPASÇILARIN ARKADAŞLARIMIZA BASKI VE TEHDİTLE DAYATTIĞI GERÇEK DIŞI...
"NORMAL HAYATIN SUÇMUŞ GİBİ GÖSTERİLMESİ" ANORMALLİĞİ
ARKADAŞIMIZ ÇAĞLA ÇELENLİOĞLU'NUN DURUŞMADAKİ İDDİALARINA CEVABIMIZ
YENİ ŞAFAK VE GÜNEŞ GAZETELERİNDEKİ GERÇEK DIŞI İDDİALARA CEVAP
SAVUNMA HAKKIMIZ NASIL ENGELLENDİ?
ARKADAŞIMIZ ECE KOÇ'UN DURUŞMADAKİ İDDİALARINA CEVABIMIZ
ARKADAŞLARIMIZ MUSTAFA ARULAR VE EMRE TEKER'İN DURUŞMALARINDAKİ...
ARKADAŞIMIZ AYÇA PARS'IN DURUŞMADAKİ İDDİALARINA CEVABIMIZ
KAMU VİCDANI YALANI
DEVLETİMİZİN VERDİĞİ SİLAH RUHSATLARI CAMİAMIZA DUYDUĞU GÜVENİN AÇIK BİR...
ASIL HEDEF İSLAM ALEMİ, TÜRKİYE, SAYIN ERDOĞAN VE AK PARTİ HÜKÜMETİ
GERÇEK MODERNLİK İSLAM DİNİNDEDİR
TV PROGRAMLARINDA SEVGİ DİLİ ESAS ALINMALIDIR
"Allah'tan tahliyemizi istirham ediyorum"
AKİT GRUBUNA AÇIK MEKTUP
"....Allahvar.com sitesi kapatıldı, düşmanım bu siteyi yapmış olsa...
GARDIROP YALANI
SAYIN DOĞU PERİNÇEK'E AÇIK MEKTUP
'CRACKED.COM' SİTESİNDEKİ İDDİALARA CEVAP
1999 KAN KAMPANYASI TAMAMEN MEŞRU VE LEGAL BİR ORGANİZASYONDUR
HAKİM VE SAVCILARIMIZ YALNIZCA KANUN, HUKUK VE VİCDANI ESAS ALMALIDIR
HARUN YAHYA KÜLLİYATININ İMHASI ÇOK VAHİM VE TARİHİ BİR HATA OLUR
DİYANET İŞLERİ BAŞKANLIĞI RAPORUNA CEVAP
İLERİ DERECEDE MODERN GÖRÜNÜM VE DEKOLTE GİYİM TARZININ NEDENLERİ
"Adnan Bey’in çevresindeki her insan hayat dolu, mutlu, cıvıl cıvıl.”
SUÇSUZ BİR GENÇ KIZ DAHA HUKUKSUZ OLARAK TUTUKLANDI
SÖZDE İTİRAFÇI VEYA MÜŞTEKİ OLMAYA ZORLANMIŞ KARDEŞLERİMİZE ACİL KURTULUŞ...
YENİ BİR SAFSATA DAHA
"Müslümanlar Kardeştir..."
"Biz silahlı suç örgütü değiliz"
MEHDİYETİ GÜNDEME GETİRMEK LİNÇ KONUSU OLMAMALI
"Zorla alıkonma, İzole bir hayat yaşama iddialarını asla kabul etiyorum"
"Adnan Bey bizi çok sever, hep onore eder"
MEDYANIN ZORAKİ "BENZERLİK KURMA" TAKTİĞİ
"Ortada silahlı suç örgütü değil sadece birbirini çok seven arkadaş...
AYÇA PARS CANIMIZ GİBİ SEVDİĞİMİZ, MELEK HUYLU, MÜMİNE KARDEŞİMİZDİR
ÇOK DEĞERLİ BİR SİYASİ BÜYÜĞÜMÜZE AÇIK MEKTUP
"ALIKONMA" SAFSATASI
KUMPASÇILARIN KORKUTARAK İFTİRACI DEVŞİRME YÖNTEMLERİ
BERİL KONCAGÜL TEHDİT ALTINDADIR, CAMİAMIZA İFTİRAYA ZORLANMAKTADIR!
TAHLİYE OLAN ARKADAŞLARIMIZ HİÇ KİMSE İÇİN HİÇBİR ZAMAN BİR BASKI UNSURU...
AV. CELAL ÜLGEN ADİL VE DÜRÜST OLMALI
AKİT TV SUNUCUSU CANER KARAER HAKKINDA ÖNEMLİ BİLGİLENDİRME
MASUM İNSANLARIN TAHLİYESİ TAMER KORKMAZ'I DA SEVİNDİRMELİDİR
"Adnan Bey için ailelerimizle arasının iyi olmadığına dair iftiralar...
"Türkiye ve İslam Dünyasını zayıflatmak istiyorlar.."
"Adnan Bey`den ASLA ŞİDDET VE BASKI GÖRMEDİM..."
"Allah rızası için 40 yıldır Türk-İslam Birliği için çabalıyoruz"
"...En ufak bir suça dahi şahit olmadım..."
"Hakkımızda çok fazla SAHTE DELİLLER ÜRETTİLER..."
"Biz FETÖNÜN ANTİSİYİZ...."
“Bu dava sürecinde.... sözde dijital delillerin ibraz edilmemesi gibi pek...
"Zaten biz birbirimizi bu kadar çok sevdiğimiz için buradayız..."
"Biz bir arkadaş grubuyuz..."
"...Biz Vakıf faaliyetlerimiz ile her zaman Devletimizin yanında olduk"
"Biz kimseyle ilgili karalama faaliyeti yapmadık..."
"...Sözde tecavüz için mi buradaki arkadaşlarımla biraraya geleceğim?!"
"...Faaliyetlerimiz herkese hitap ediyor ..."
"Bizim amacımız şatafat içinde yaşamak değil, hiç kimsenin hitap edemediği...
"İnancım gereği ben insanlara yardım ederim"
"Ne yapsa "zorla" diyorlar. Zorla Gülümsüyor, Zorla, Zorla olur mu?"
"Bizim bir arada olma amacımız örgüt kurmak değil. ilmi mücadele...
"Biz birbirimizi Allah için seven.. arkadaşlarız"
"Polisler geldi, hangi eve operasyon yapacağız derlerken, balkona çıkıp...
"Biz örgüt değiliz"
"Devletimizi desteklediğimiz çok hayırlı faaliyetlerimiz var, Bunlar...
"Biz Allah`tan Razıyız Allah da Bizlerden Razı olur inşaAllah"
"İddia edildiği gibi katı bir ortam olsa 40-50 yıl niye kalalım?"
"Neden cömertsin?" diye soruyorlar
"İngiliz Derin Devleti bunu duyunca çıldırdı..."
"Biz Milli değerler etrafında birleşmiş bir sivil toplum kuruluşuyuz"
"Bir imza atıp dışarı çıkmayı ben de bilirim. Ama iftira büyük suçtur."
"Ben varlıklı bir aileden geliyorum, Saat koleksiyonum var"
"Silahlı suç örgütü iddiası tamamen asılsızdır, yalandır, iftiradır."
"Bizim yaptığımız tek şey Allah'ın yaratışını anlatmaktır."
"Almanya'da İslamofobi var, İslam düşmanları var..."
Bir örgüt olsak devlet bizimle faaliyette bulunur mu?
DAVAMIZ METAFİZİKTİR – 1. BÖLÜM
DAVAMIZ METAFİZİKTİR – 2. BÖLÜM
MAHKEME SÜRECİNDE SİLİVRİ CEZAEVİNDE YAŞANAN EZİYET VE ZULÜMLER
"Ben Sayın Adnan Oktar `dan hiçbir zaman Şiddet, Eziyet, Baskı görmedim."
DAVA DOSYASINDAKİ CİNSELLİK KONULU İDDİALAR TÜMÜYLE GEÇERSİZDİR
DURUŞMALARIN İLK HAFTASI
"İNFAK" SUÇ DEĞİL, KURAN'IN FARZ KILDIĞI BİR İBADETTİR
GERÇEK TURNİKE SİSTEMİ GENELEVLERDE
Adnan Oktar davasının ilk duruşması bugün yapıldı.
AVK. UĞUR POYRAZ: "MEDYADA FIRTINA ESTİRİLEREK KAMUOYU ŞARTLANDIRILDI,...
Adnan Oktar'ın itirafçılığa zorlanan arkadaşlarına sosyal medyadan destek...
Adnan Oktar suç örgütü değildir açıklaması.
Adnan Oktar'ın cezaevinden Odatv'ye yazdığı mektubu
Adnan Oktar'dan Cumhurbaşkanı Sayın Recep Tayyip Erdoğan'a mektup
Casuslukla suçlanmışlardı, milli çıktılar.
TBAV çevresinden "Bizler suç örgütü değiliz,kardeşiz" açıklaması
Bu sitelerin ne zararı var!
Adnan Oktar ve arkadaşları 15 Temmuz'da ne yaptılar?
Sibel Yılmaztürk'ün cezaevinden mektubu
İğrenç ve münasebsiz iftiraya ağabey Kenan Oktar'dan açıklama geldi.
Adnan Oktar ve arkadaşlarına Emniyet Müdürlüğü önünde destek ve açıklama...
Adnan Oktar hakkında yapılan sokak röportajında vatandaşların görüşü
Karar gazetesi yazarı Yıldıray Oğur'dan Adnan Oktar operasyonu...
Cumhurbaşkanı Sayın Recep Tayyip Erdoğan'dan Adnan Oktar ile ilgili...
Ahmet Hakan'nın Ceylan Özgül şüphesi.
HarunYahya eserlerinin engellenmesi, yaratılış inancının etkisini kırmayı...
Kedicikler 50bin liraya itirafçı oldu.
Adnan Oktar ve arkadaşlarına yönelik operasyonda silahlar ruhsatlı ve...
FETÖ'cü savcının davayı kapattığı haberi asılsız çıktı.
Adnan Oktar ve arkadaşlarının davasında mali suç yok...
Cemaat ve Vakıfları tedirgin eden haksız operasyon: Adnan Oktar operasyonu...
Tutukluluk süreleri baskı ve zorluk ile işkenceye dönüşüyor.
Adnan Oktar’ın Cezaevi Fotoğrafları Ortaya Çıktı!
"Milyar tane evladım olsa, milyarını ve kendi canımı Adnan Oktar'a feda...
Adnan Oktar davasında baskı ve zorla itirafçılık konusu tartışıldı.
Adnan Oktar ve arkadaşlarının davasında iftiracılık müessesesine dikkat...
Adnan Oktar davasında hukuki açıklama
Adnan Oktar ve Arkadaşlarının Masak Raporlarında Komik rakamlar
Adnan Oktar ve Arkadaşlarının tutukluluk süresi hukuku zedeledi.
Adnan Oktar'ın Museviler ile görüşmesi...
Adnan Oktar ve arkadaşlarına yönelik suçlamalara cevap verilen web sitesi...
Adnan Oktar ve arkadaşlarına karşı İngiliz Derin Devleti hareketi!
Adnan Oktar iddianamesinde yer alan şikayetçi ve mağdurlar baskı altında...
Adnan Oktar iddianamesi hazırlandı.
SAYIN NEDİM ŞENER'E AÇIK MEKTUP
Adnan Oktar ve Nazarbayev gerçeği!
En kolay isnat edilen suç cinsel suçlar Adnan Oktar ve Arkadaşlarına...
Adnan Oktar kaçmamış!
BİR KISIM MEDYA KURULUŞLARINA ÇAĞRI !!!
FİŞLEME SAFSATASI
İSA TATLICAN: BİR HUSUMETLİ PORTRESİ
MÜMİNLERİN YARDIMLAŞMASI VE DAYANIŞMASI ALLAH'IN EMRİDİR
SİLİVRİ CEZAEVİNDE YAŞANAN İNSAN HAKLARI İHLALLERİ
GÜLÜNÇ VE ASILSIZ "KAÇIŞ" YALANI
ABDURRAHMAN DİLİPAK BİLMELİDİR Kİ KURAN’A GÖRE, ZİNA İFTİRASI ATANIN...
YALANLAR BİTMİYOR
SAÇ MODELİ ÜZERİNDEN KARA PROPAGANDA
TAHLİYE EDİLENLERE LİNÇ KAMPANYASI ÇOK YANLIŞ
MEDYA MASALLARI ASPARAGAS ÇIKMAYA DEVAM EDİYOR
Adnan Oktar ve Arkadaşlarının ilk duruşma tarihi belli oldu.
AKİT TV VE YENİ AKİT GAZETESİNE ÖNEMLİ NASİHAT
YAŞAR OKUYAN AĞABEYİMİZE AÇIK MEKTUP
KARA PARA AKLAMA İDDİALARINA CEVAP
Adnan Oktar ve FETÖ bağlantısı olmadığı ortaya çıktı.
TAKVİM GAZETESİNİN ALGI OPERASYONU
Adnan Oktar ve Arkadaşlarına yönelik suçlamaların iftira olduğu anlaşıldı.
"Bizler Suç Örgütü Değiliz..."